Skip to main content.

Saturday, January 14, 2006

Frodo. Frodo lives. Lives - not lives. It's time to talk about the Frodo lives we're living.

Do a restrictive search of "Frodo Lives" and you get 37,200 hits. But just about none of these are relevant to our Frodo lives. On the way to talking about what I mean, here are few examples of what searching for Frodo lives gets you.

You can find a genealogy of hobbits, including Frodo. You can explore reminiscences of a youth spent reading LOTR and the impact of seeing The Fellowship of the Rings.

You can read an academic discussion of J.R.R. Tolkein in English and Italian.

At Frodo Lives . . . within us now, you can find links to all things LOTR.

You can find a Salon movie review of LOTR, and you can find the Top 7 Movies for "Frodo Baggins Types.

You can even find marketing advice gleaned from LOTR: Frodo's Journey: What It Can Teach You About Marketing Your Small Business - Here are 10 things you can learn about marketing your small business from the Lord of the Rings trilogy.

. . . . O . . . kay. . . .

But I'm talking about lives - not lives.

These past few years, who among us has not been living Frodo lives?

Whether you read the book or saw the movie or both . . . multiple times, the things that made the greatest impression on most of us was the despair Frodo and all the Fellowship of the Ring felt at undertaking their mission. They faced deadly challenges in troubled times. They could choose not to take the challenge, but if they did, evil would rule the world.

Or they could take up the challenge, try their hardest but be killed or wounded in body and spirit, and evil would overtake the world. Or they could take up the challenge, endure horrors, be wounded in body and spirit . . . and just maybe evil would be destroyed. Through their efforts the world would go on, not quite as before, though. The world would be left with less magic and less wonder, but regular people could live their lives outside the shadow of evil.

Admit it. During your darkest moments these past few years, doesn't that feel like what we have been going through?

Frodo constantly wishes he had never been burdened with The Ring, wishes someone other than he, better than he could destroy it, wishes he had never been eye to eye with true evil. He longs to give The Ring to someone else, to go home and hide.

But Gandalf constantly reminds him - and us - that we are not allowed to choose the times we live in. All we can choose is how we act in the troubled times we have.

Frodo's woes and challenges feel like ours today.

Tolkien wrote LOTR in the midst of WW II. As he told the Frodo's story of evil overtaking the world, he lived with the reality that evil was in the process of taking over the world.

But all was not dark then, nor is it now. Tolkien's message to us is: As strong as evil can be, even stronger are the virtues of love, faith, friendship, fellowship, honor, duty, loyalty, nobility of spirit, music, and art, and the willingness to sacrifice oneself for the good of others - even when those others are silly, imprudent, and wholly undeserving.

This is not all. LOTR has additional messages for our time.

Throughout the book evil creeps in when people turn away from truth and duty and beauty and, instead, listen to fear and compromise, when they turn from doing what is right to doing what seems expedient or prudent. I'm not namin' names, but I think we all can think of examples . . . maybe even the way we are living.

The slogan "Frodo lives" tells us that when confronted with evil we must live Frodo lives.

Frodo's time is past. His duty is done. This is our time. Frodo must live within us all now.

Comments

8 comments

[1]
And for those who despair. http://www.thebattleforamer...

Posted by shirah at Saturday, January 14, 2006 10:36:12

[2]
Good discussion on this same story at Kos.
http://www.dailykos.com/sto...

Posted by shirah at Saturday, January 14, 2006 10:36:40

[3]
Thanks, shirah. Also for the dKos link. I'm not a huge LOTR fan, although I enjoyed the books and movies. But you hit on something I've been thinking for the past five years -- haven't these people ever read a book? Can't they tell who the bad guys are? I mean, honestly!

After the last Star Wars movie came out, there were even a couple of posts on right-wing sites defending the dark side!

Posted by Izzy at Saturday, January 14, 2006 13:45:57

[4]
Defending the Dark Side? Well, I guess they have no choice, given which side they they have cast their lot with.

Posted by shirah at Saturday, January 14, 2006 14:59:02

[5]
I remember going to see the first movie in December, 2001, and having the exact same feelings. When Gandalf gives Frodo that talk in Mordor, I remember feeling the same. And again, when watching the DVD commentary about hoping despite facing a seemingly hopeless situation. It gave me hope.

During that first movie I sat next to a woman who was also there alone, and we talked. Her sons were both Marines, one of them in Afghanistan.

That was also about the time I went to my first political meeting, where Scott Camil, one of the Gainesville Eight, spoke. I wonder if I have an FBI file.

Posted by Julie O. at Saturday, January 14, 2006 21:54:24

[6]
You'll have to read the books. The movies do a pretty good job of telling the story, but the books are really wonderful. The Ents are more interesting and more majestic in the books, for example.

I read the books when I was a kid and then re-read them after the first movie came out. I was stunned by how whole pages of the books came back to me even decades after that first reading.

Posted by shirah at Sunday, January 15, 2006 17:37:03

[7]
You know, although I agree with all that was said in that Battle for America video, I thought it was really cheesy.

Posted by environmentalist at Monday, January 16, 2006 15:48:17

[8]
Aw, environmentalist, ya old softie.

Posted by shirah at Monday, January 16, 2006 16:53:04

Add Comment

This item is closed, it's not possible to add new comments to it or to vote on it

Buy Viagra