Skip to main content.

Monday, July 11, 2005

A new study, Effects of the Federal Estate Tax on Farms and Small Businesses by the Congressional Budget Office, shows that the Estate Tax does not hurt family farms and businesses.

The Senate will soon vote on repealing the Estate Tax. This study has important information for those of us in states like Colorado, whose Senators may soon vote in favor of repeal.

A new study, Effects of the Federal Estate Tax on Farms and Small Businesses by the Congressional Budget Office, shows that the Estate Tax does not hurt family farms and businesses.

The Senate will soon vote on repealing the Estate Tax. This study has important information for those of us in states like Colorado, whose Senators may soon vote in favor of repeal.

An article, "Few Wealthy Farmers Owe Estate Taxes, Report Says" by David Kay Johnston in the July 10 New York Times summarizes the CBO study. Here are some quotes from this article:

"The number of farms on which estate tax is owed when the owners die has fallen by 82 percent since 2000, to just 300 farms..."

"All but 27 farmers left enough liquid assets to pay taxes owed, the budget office found, although it hinted that the actual number might be zero."

"The estate tax raised an estimated $23.4 billion last year. Repeal would shift part of the burden of taxes off the fortunes left by the richest 1 percent of Americans, some of whose fortunes were never taxed, onto the general population. The lost revenue could be made up in three ways: through higher income taxes; reduced government services; or more borrowing, which would pass the burden of current government spending to future generations."

The CBO study debunks the myth, promoted by Senator Wayne Allard (R-CO) and others, that the Estate Tax hurts family farms and businesses.

Only estates over $1.5 million, $3 million for a couple, are subject to the federal Estate Tax. The vast majority of money collected through this tax is on very large estates, much of which is unrealized capital gains which has not yet been taxed even once. This debunks another myth: that the Estate Tax is unfair because it constitutes "double taxation". Besides, money is usually taxed when it changes hands while flowing through the economy, and the Estate Tax is no different.

More details on the Estate Tax are at United for a Fair Economy .

Then there's the issue of basic fairness: why should a wealthy few have millions of dollars handed to them, tax free, while the rest of us not only have to work for a living, but have to pay taxes on what we earn?

If the Estate Tax is repealed, a few wealthy families will accumulate vast fortunes, both tax-free and work-free. This threatens democracy itself. That's because wealth buys political power, influence, and access to elected officials. The great Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis once wrote, "We can have a democratic society or we can have great concentrated wealth in the hands of the few. We cannot have both."

Let's not mince words: any Senator who votes to repeal the Estate Tax is waging class warfare on behalf of the richest 1%, against the other 99%. They favor plutocracy over democracy. They want the very rich to receive money without working for it, and without paying taxes on it.

So, if you want your Senators to vote against repealing the Estate Tax, now is the time to tell them. Their addresses and phone numbers are here .

Comments

5 comments

[1]
Thanks for the info. I'm amazed how many smart people have fallen for the myth about small family businesses being hit -- it's important for us to have stats to show what the actual situation is. Great Brandeis quote, too!

Posted by DCvote at Monday, July 11, 2005 15:06:55

[2]
On a similar note, I received this from the Center for Budget Policy and Priorities this morning:

Senator Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.), an ardent champion of permanently repealing the estate tax, is reportedly pushing for a vote this summer on a proposal that would retain a very small estate tax. His most recent proposal would reportedly set the exemption from the tax at $8 million (which amounts to $16 million for a couple) and set the estate tax rate equal to the capital gains tax rate, which currently is 15 percent.

The Urban Institute-Brookings Institution Tax Policy Center estimates than an estate tax combining a 15 percent rate with an exemption of $8 million per individual would lose nearly 93 percent of the estate revenue that would be lost if the estate tax were completely repealed. That is, it would preserve only 7 percent of the revenue that would be lost under repeal, despite the severe long-term fiscal problems the nation faces.

Full report here >> http://www.cbpp.org/7-7-05t...

Posted by em dash at Monday, July 11, 2005 15:55:31

[3]
I truly believe initiatives like this and the privatization of Social Security are intended to destabilize the economic power of the middle class and to increase the ever-tightening grip of control on this nation's wealth by the oligarchic class.

With fewer dependable annual revenues flowing into the US treasury, middle class programs such as Student Loans, Medicare/caid, and federally-insured mortgage programs will continue to be cut as a result of skyrocketing deficit spending and a ratcheting up of military expenditures for the War on Terra.

Now is the time for Populist Democrats and those of either party that value fiscal responsibility to come out from hiding and start speaking truth to power before it is too late.

Posted by em dash at Monday, July 11, 2005 16:00:40

[4]
There's a sad level of misinformation out there on this issue. My grandmother was so frightened of the estate tax (something that would never apply to her she had so little "estate") she made some very bad decisions she was persuaded would protect her -- and lost what little "estate" she had.

I'm sure she's not the only one this has happened to.

Posted by shirah at Tuesday, July 12, 2005 06:11:03

[5]
Your grandmother's experience is too common. I work with a number of donors—from those with incredible high net worth to good folks with modest means who want to the right thing.

I never cease to be amazed at the lack of personal financial knowledge. The "death tax" crap is a convenient bogeyman for a generation who grew up during the Depression and knows what it's like to lose everything.

Posted by em dash at Tuesday, July 12, 2005 11:58:22

Add Comment

This item is closed, it's not possible to add new comments to it or to vote on it

Buy Viagra